I thought we were being honest - What you say when you realize you’ve been played like a fidd

What you say when you realize you’ve been played like a fiddle.

'I thought we were being honest!' said the guy who had 7 different names on his phone.

'I thought we were being honest!' said the girl who had 10 different boyfriends in 2 months.

'I thought we were being honest!' said the kid who said he had a dog but it was actually a cat.