I didn't know I was playing church league softball
A fancy way of saying you got served a lukewarm beer that tastes like regret and old socks.
My cousin said, 'I didn't know I was playing church league softball' after he took one sip of my beer.
My mom texted me, 'I didn't know I was playing church league softball' after I gave her my grandpa’s old beer.
My friend screamed, 'I didn't know I was playing church league softball' after I poured beer into his soup.